Community Update

Digital Empowerment Toolkit Now Available!

At World Pulse, we recognize the need for ongoing learning—for you and for your community! Our toolkits aim to provide the resources you need to advance your social change work.

We are excited to introduce our Digital Empowerment Trainers’ Toolkit, a dynamic resource to help you bring the benefits of connecting online to women in your community. Check it out today! »

With awareness and education, online anonymity does more good than harm

images.jpg

Anonymity is used well before the Internet so that people could express themselves freely and protect their own privacy in certain political and social contexts. On another hand, anonymity can be used to perpetrate crime and violate privacy. Anonymity is a double-edged knife.

Protection vs. credibility

In Syria, most activists used alias names to conceal their identities, including me. Anonymity, in this case, was used as a method to protect an activist operating inside Syria from being arrested and imprisoned¹, and used by activists outside Syria to protect family members inside Syria, or to avoid bullying online and offline. However, the issue of credibility was raised. A committed individual to a cause, or an activist, who uses a pseudonym needs time to prove that the information he/she providing is not made up. The dictatorship exploited this doubt by assigning a group of its supporters to pretend that they were activists and publish unreal news, pictures, and even videos in order to weaken any trust an anonymous activist may have gained.

But did anonymity by itself protect the activists, especially those working inside Syria? The Syrian regime used the Internet to track activists, even the anonymous ones. A piece of Skype encryption software downloaded by Syrian activists was later discovered to be malware that allows the attacker to capture webcam activity, steal passwords and accounts and send it all to a Syrian IP address.² I remember how this affected many activists and in Syria; even if the activist used an anonymous name, his identity could be revealed by tracking the IP address if a proxy bypass was not used.

A Syrian activist who specialises in IT and works in spreading awareness about Internet security among Syrian civil activists, said in an interview that using a pseudonym is not as effective as using certain protection programmes like TOR.³ He added that news published by activists using alias names are not recognised as official and documented.

In my opinion, anonymity can narrow the range of cyber attackers. It will conceal one's identity from the inexperienced users in IT, or those who violently disagree with one's opinions, so their harmful impact will not likely extend past sending hate messages.

Empowerment vs. cyberbullying and harassment

The Internet can provide a medium for different groups of people to gain support and self-empowerment. From my personal experience with an online women’s group, I know that anonymity can give a voice to more vulnerable groups in society such as women, ethnic minorities, and even whistleblowers.

I used a pseudonym myself during my activities with an organisation called World Pulse to train women to be the voice of their communities as citizen journalists. It was a hub for women from all around the world to share their experiences and hardships. Some of the women had been subjected to rape and sexual harassment and wanted to share their experiences and hear from other women, sharing in a healing process together after going through such painful experiences. Other women living in conservative communities hide their identities when sharing a simple opinion that might be considered offensive to the entire tribe or family, and the woman might be punished for that. Women seek advice, consultation, opportunities, ideas, and empowerment.

In another example, a study showed that social media can provide children with social and identity development, and this would encourage civic involvement later.⁴

Anonymity can also help patients who want to talk about certain health conditions but don’t want to identify themselves. Patient suffering from a disease transmitted sexually or from drug addiction might seek help and comfort online while still keeping their identities private.

But anonymity can be used for gender-based bullying and sexual harassment. The Internet can provide a good cover for pathological behaviours. All over social networks many people believe that they can say almost everything they want as long as their identities are disguised online. Currently in the MENA region, social media is full of curses, humiliations, bad language, bullying and harassment. The sectarian issue in the region is stirring online name-calling and hate messages. Although this hostility is also expressed offline, online it gets uglier under hidden identities.

One statement about sexual harassment argued that "the phenomenon of sexual harassment on the Internet downplays the positive process of empowerment that women gain from egalitarian use of the Internet."⁵ Any woman online might be harassed as the perpetrators think they can get away with it as long as no one knows who the perpetrator is.

Anonymity is also used to hide the identities of online child abuses. A study showed that 1 in every 5 children who use the Internet might be approached sexually since the predators go online with less risk and constraints they might face in the real world because of the anonymous nature of the Internet⁶. Anonymity on the other hand, is also used by police and child protection groups to monitor and catch predators hiding behind their screens.

There is also the issue of accountability when going anonymous online. One viewpoint states that to hold someone accountable and be brought to justice, then he/she should be identified. If people remain anonymous, then they will not be identified and it will be impossible to hold them accountable when they commit a crime.⁷ The previous point claims that anonymity might threaten society’s freedom.

Do you want to appear online?

Though the latter point might be taken into consideration, but it is an exaggeration to claim it will threaten the freedom of a society. Being anonymous is a free decision and act, especially in today's cyberspace where one can appear just by a simple search on Google. An employer can check you out, a friend or a foe can find you online when you provide your name. Anonymity provides you with privacy to express your thoughts freely in conservative or politically oppressed atmospheres without further implications in the real world.

Writing with a real name will associate the writer with content, enforced accountability and prevents bad Internet practices. Online anonymity will allow expression of opinion without repercussion, fuels creativity and experimentation, and encourage authentic content sharing⁸.

In my opinion, anonymity must be allowed and practiced, however, laws must be made to protect anonymous freedom of expression and at the same time prevent cyberbullying and harassment. Parents and teachers must talk to their kids on how to protect themselves and report when they are approached in an inappropriate way. Spreading awareness in the issue of anonymity is crucial for protection and respect while engaging in the larger world online.

References

1- Syrian Activists Remain Anonymous Amid Opposition Work - Hama, Syria
http://www.demotix.com/news/2107022/syrian-activists-remain-anonymous-am...
2- In Syria, the Cyberwar Intensifies
http://www.oiip.ac.at/publikationen/publikationen-detail/article/105/in-...
3- التكنولوجيا والثورة السورية
http://syrianoor.net/revto/3731
4- Kids online: Social media sites can help develop identity, study says
http://www.csmonitor.com/The-Culture/Family/Modern-Parenthood/2013/0131/...
5- Sexual Harassment on the Internet
http://construct.haifa.ac.il/~azy/SexualHarassmentBarak.pdf
6- Sexual Predators: Using Internet Anonymity to Lure Kids
http://www.awarenesstech.com/Parental/Articles/sexual-predators.html
7- Anonymity on the Internet: Why the Price May Be Too High
http://www.csl.mtu.edu/cs6461/www/Reading/Davenport02.pdf
8- Infographic: The Pros and Cons of Online & Social Anonymity vs. Transparency
http://www.dr4ward.com/dr4ward/2011/05/the-pros-and-cons-of-online-anony...

This story was written for World Pulse’s Women Weave the Web Digital Action Campaign. Learn more »

Downloads

Comments

Idara's picture

Freedom of Anonimity

I agree with you, the pros for anonymity online out weighs the cons. Sometimes when people do not use their real names, they tend to be more committed to the course, because the fears of arrest or repercussions is not so real as using their real names.

Hummingbird's picture

Dear Idara, When I started

Dear Idara,

When I started my activism, many people used to ask me why don't I use my real name? Some were unable to understand my anonymity to avoid being followed up and monitored. But now I realized that anonymity is my right to protect my identity, my activism and the people I love. Some people might say that how can we trust someone we don't know? But they miss the point, the issue is not the person talking, the issue here is the cause.

Thank you for your comment my dear sister. Love.

A drop of rain can revive the earth, be the drop.

Hummingbird

Osai's picture

I agree

Dear Hummingbird,

I agree with you. Anonymity saves you from prejudice. There are stereotypes based on your background, race, status etc that can affect how people treat you or receive your message. Anonymity shields you so that people treat as you are - a human being with life and expression.

Best wishes,
Osai

Twitter: @livingtruely

Thank you very much sister have found the time to share with us, thank you also for the board I love it. Continues
Hi

sylvie

Hi Hummingbird,
I found your article really interesting - especially the problems facing Syrian activists and how it's necessary to keep one step ahead of the cyber spies.

The question of anonymity is interesting - I recently signed a peptition regarding extending the proposed government enquiry into paedophilia in the UK to the island of Jersey - and then I noticed that the originator of the petition was anonymous. Under such circumstances, I can understand it - and also with regard to the need for anonymity in Syria and other areas of the world where civil/military conflict is putting people's lives at risk. But it is also a sad and terrible reflection of many different kinds of injustices in our societies. I think the role of World Pulse in enabling women to share their stories and learn about other ways of seeing things gives us a better chance of ground-root changes. Maybe it's a dream, but it would be wonderful to live in a world where everyone felt safe to stand up and be named.

Best wishes for your work and your writing,

Fiona

Fiona McKenzie

Magazine »

Read global coverage through women's eyes

Inside Congo's Growing Sisterhood

Inside Congo's Growing Sisterhood

Community »

Connect with women on the ground worldwide

PAKISTAN: They Went to School and Never Came Back

PAKISTAN: They Went to School and Never Came Back

Campaigns »

Be heard at influential forums

WWW: Women Weave the Web

WWW: Women Weave the Web

Programs »

Help us train women citizen journalists

World Pulse Voices of Our Future

World Pulse Voices of Our Future

Blog »

Read the latest from World Pulse headquarters

Announcing Our Prize Winners!

Announcing Our Prize Winners!

Partners »

Join forces with our wide network of partners

Nobel Women's Initiative

Nobel Women's Initiative