Community Update

World Pulse Toolkits Available!

At World Pulse, we recognize the need for ongoing learning—for you and for your community! Our toolkits are all available here.

We are especially excited to share our signature Citizen Journalism and Digital Empowerment Curriculum. Start learning today!

Scintillating Silhouettes of Digital Consumerism

Scintillating Silhouettes of Digital Consumerism
Sreetanwi Chakraborty

“The paramount doctrine of the economic and technological euphoria of recent decades has been that everything depends on innovation. It was understood as desirable, and even necessary, that we should go on and on from one technological innovation to the next, which would cause the economy to “grow” and make everything better and better. This of course implied at every point a hatred of the past, of all things inherited and free. All things superseded in our progress of innovations, whatever their value might have been, were discounted as of no value at all.”
( Wendel Berry )

I would definitely like to commence this topic with a segment of my personal experience, when I was loitering inside a grotesquely designed shopping mall in Kokata. Inside a renowned gadget store I found two women bargaining for a mobile phone. One was referred to as the maidservant of the household, and the other lady was the employer, an orthopedic surgeon’s wife. The maidservant wanted a duplicate product, a carbon copy of the same mobile that her ‘madam’ had just bought. Her enthusiasm was triggered, because that digital thingamajig could allow her to impress her boyfriend with megapixelled images of her facial and bodily contours, as the mobile screen could adjust light and shadows in the pictures automatically, and could eradicate physical anomalies in the photo version to the maximum limit.

A second case also captured my attention, regarding the formidable effects of digital extravaganza. During the anti-eviction movement on 30th March 2012, in Nonadanga, a place that had temporary slums and shanties, in Kasba area of Kolkata, the Bartaman (a Bengali newspaper) reported unimaginable plight of the protesters. One of the female protesters commented that, she had lost her ‘branded television and mobile set’, and claimed that, more than anything else this was an irreparable loss to her. In fact, the irreconcilable discrepancy between those who are having all the facilities in life, and those who are perpetually deprived of even the basic minimum necessities, is glaring, but consciously and subconsciously, they also desire for all the advertized, digitalized, and morphed products that can enable them recuperate from the condition of perennial and sporadic drudgery.

A pertinent question that nudges me at this juncture is that, what is the digital debate all about? Is it, in any way, trying to subvert all the preconceived notions about the welfare and lifestyle of these destitute, the lower class women, or, is the digital revolution, in some way, embarking upon a catastrophic journey to fabricate a world of temporary illusion for them, where these mason-women, rag-pickers, domestic maidservants, female tea-stall owners, poultry retainers, tea-garden laborers, municipality scavengers, part-time ‘ayah’s (untrained nursing helps), milk-maids, and female construction workers are entrapped into the computerized marketing procedures, billboards with swanky gadgets displayed on them, the spicy concoctions which promise to make their bland dishes delectable, essentially make them oblivious of the multiple faces of poverty and the relentless struggle with a drunkard husband, a debauch male partner, or their sultry afternoons and insipid nights at the red light areas of Kolkata.

Commercial television channels have intrinsically infringed as the by-products and disseminators of a very complicated concept of modernization and urbanization, and they have penetrated even the remotest parts of West Bengal and other surrounding areas. The behavioral patterns, psychological framework and the idea about their own ‘body’ have inculcated in these lower class women, an urge to have the most glistening of all beauty products, fairness creams that will boost their confidence and somehow allow them to progress a step further in the social hierarchy and ‘look’ like the middle class, well-to-do females. Images used in print media, magazine covers, advertisement of multinational products, and a complete flourishing of technology and scientific innovations have created a hyper-real world for these women, who fail to differentiate between the glittering tinsel world, and the position they occupy in the overall social structure.

If we scrutinize the temporary consequences, as well as the concrete impact of the digital or the cyber cataclysm on Kolkata’s culture of servitude, it is revealed that, although the maidservants, domestic workers, and part time or full time helpers are considered to be an integral part of the ‘bhadralok’( a parochial view of part of the educated middle class Bengali people), disparities still remain, and Indrani Sen has contemplated in her book Are You Being Served that the television and ultramodern marketing strategies have almost blurred the distinction between the employers and the employed, where, even if the actual picture remains the archetypal- they eat, but only after we have finished our food, they also participate in our family drama, although they are relegated to the role of bit players. For recognizing one aspect of the digital deliberations, it can be said that, for these women who generally belong to the marginal, non-advantaged positions of the society, the irresistible temptation of a luxurious lifestyle, computer, internet, laptops, tablets, wi-fi connectivity, motorcycles, lipsticks, LCDs, LEDs, data cards, supersonic channel loaders, computer courses, and even getting admitted in some discounted spoken English lessons at the end of their daily activities, in reality, portray the unmitigated onslaught of the frantic fatality of globalization and digital excess, and how these women remain vulnerable to these. The digital flirtations emphasize not just a spatial or temporal shift for these women whose roles have been traditionally selected, codified, structured and socially demarcated as less significant or mediocre, or secondary among the more educated, privileged or economically solvent females, but a conspicuous truth is also laid bare about their newly-achieved positions. The incessant dichotomy between the ‘central’ and ‘peripheral’ space which these women occupy, and the whirlpool of numerous complexities that affect these women, is really to be examined by us, before we usher in another grand celebration of the National Women’s Day this year. The valorizing of unprecedented digital connectivity and networking destabilizes and reprimands the social disparities among these subordinate class workers who actually create and recreate, capture and recapture their moulded ‘images’ as they wanted them to be. To present themselves in shades of shimmering pink photo-arts, to wrap their discomfitures in marvelous salwar suits (although, for most of the domestic staffs, they come as second-hand, used material from their employers!) is an extraordinary achievement for them. Their physical, mental scars, all of their social aberrations are then teased at, and finally devoured by the more rhythmic inclusion and tempo of the new cyber mania, recorded and transmitted through money, a new wave of collective Capitalism where the binaries of deformity no longer exist, but a promotional courage ratify these women to be in their new ‘avatar’s, in semblance with the larger circle of others.

‘The effects of technology’, in the words of the perceptive media theorist Harbert McLuhan, ‘do not occur at the levels of opinions or concepts’, rather, they transform patterns of perception. Rampant usage of digital equipments, and a constant obsession with digital facts, figures, pictures and contents actually paralyze the life of either Rowma, or Sushma, or Fulki, or Tiya, as they wait, want and long to be ‘seen’, to be visualized as the members of the same planet to which their employers, or the children of their employers belong. Rapid and autonomous access to education, social networking sites, communication groups, pen-friend circle, business advertisements, e-banking, commercialization of the realty firms, estate building layouts with swimming pools, Jacuzzi, joggers’ park and mechanized gymnasiums, database available in call centres, the association with what have erstwhile been considered as the ‘finer’ things of life, have all catapulted these women not only to an economically superior position, than those who just live the BPL lives in rural villages, or even, their own housemates, sister-in-laws, other female friends, or co-passengers in train. In her celebrated book Zeroes and Ones Sadie Plant expresses eloquently how the cyberspace acts as a liberating zone for the women, and she thinks the textual nature of the internet lends itself to ‘the female’. Her adroit portrayal of the ‘zeroes’ as females and the ‘ones’ as phallic and male, predicts that the digital future can be said to be feminine, distributed, non-linear, an innovative world order where the phallic ones are displaced by the zeroes. Plant in this connection can be considered one of the leading harbingers of cyberfeminism, thwarting the previous conceptions of technology as essentially masculine.

Everyday, in local trains that connect Sealdah to Dankuni, or Howrah to Bandel, or Shalimar station to some other unknown, less remarkable, prehistoric places, we see women jostling in crowded compartments of the ‘vendor’ class; women travelling by train, commuting from obscure villages near Lakshmikantapur, or Taki, Hasnabad, Karimpur, or Sandeshkhali, not just to earn a decent livelihood, but also to include themselves in the tantalizing world of the city; they are found staring vacantly at what the fashionable car showrooms or the glistening façade of a branded garment store has to offer, considering the ‘digital’ images, style sheets, labeling, pixelled beauty, conglomeration of perfect, size-zero models as the basic parameters of rising in a social hierarchy, thus making it quite obvious that digital consumerism has overpowered them completely. It is a slice of my thought, that, whereas railways connected the suburbs to the metropolitan cities, they have also become sites for the perpetuation and regeneration of social evils like child trafficking, molestation, drug-peddling, prostitution and other sorts of anti-social activity. The number of escort services, call girls, phone and get a friend who will satisfy all your needs, and sophisticated massage parlours that have mushroomed all over the suburban areas like New Barrackpore, Ashokenagar or Habra ( and not forgetting our very own Kolkata!) have been instrumental in aggravating and nurturing these social evils and facilitation of sex over, via and through internet, wi-fi, cheap mobile marketing and attraction of money and long-term fixed deposits. The images of several girls have been distorted, re-configured, re-textured, morphed and drastically changed and circulated in obscene websites. On a microscopic level, it was also understood, as different newspapers generated facts that many of the girls work as part-time call girls only to receive some extra money, and work either in a tea-stall, or as a maidservant, or in a construction site thrice a week, or a flower-seller, or a vegetable-vendor. They justify their acts, disregarding any sort of flippant moral scruples that all good girls or women of the society are endowed with. They are just like the college students, or any other woman on the street. Unlike the stereotypical prostitutes on the streets, they feel liberated; they are vociferous about their personal sexual choices, they can ‘edit’, ‘select’, ‘control’, ‘delete’, or ‘alter’ their clients, after entering the business by placing their own computerized advertisements on public classified sites, and often keeping the work a strict hush hush to their families. At this point I found it relevant to concentrate on what Scott Cunningham, an economist at Baylor University, who has studied the impact of internet on prostitution markets, has said: “When you take the profile of internet prostitutes versus street prostitutes, you find there’s more education and that more work temporarily, and then exit. They also are significantly less likely to work for a pimp”. But the question still hovers around – does the digital debate has only positive ramifications, or, is it, in essence, trying to suppress and objectify simultaneously, the feminine self, the pivotal role of these females in the society.

As for my personal experience with a woman, about thirty-five year old, who works as a maidservant in one of the most affluent areas of Ekdalia, in South Kolkata, her life was not so smooth even after all the grotesque humour that digital market had to offer her. She actually participated in a dual income activity circle, she had been married off to a carpenter of ‘Bongaon’ at a very early age, she became vulnerable to the sordid miscalculations of pregnancy, as well as social and cultural atrocities like domestic violence, as well as several oppressions in the house of her employer. The person whom once she fondly called ‘dada’ (elder brother) had forced her into distorted sex performance (which is prohibited by the Indian Penal Code), photographed her naked with his own self, morphed her pictures, deleted his own from those, and circulated these on social media and pornographic sites. Incidentally, this man was also a computer engineer and he had made an unproductive use of the digital dexterity. Thus, a sufficient technological knowledge on the part of the man actually placed him in a superior position when compared to the utter ignorance of the woman in economic, political, social, technological, and educational matters. Several cases have been registered both with Kolkata as well as Barasat and the entire West Bengal police, where digital crime records have soared beyond imagination, where school drop-out girls, farmers’ wives, brick-kiln labourers, detergent industry workers( female) are either tempted to experience a pre-nuptial carnal pleasure with their prospective grooms, who relish a one-night stand with their girlfriends, and then either rape them, or engage them in flesh-trafficking, or else, channelize, synchronize, and mobilize distorted images of these girls or women, for a lucrative sum. This in the process defames these women and mentally paralyzes them beyond any sort of recovery.

Digital insurgency is a continuous process and more than a debate, it can be considered to be an incredible phenomenon that has multifarious consequences; both the positive and the negative aspects jostle for identification, and the collective synthesis is almost impossible. What remains is a fragmented kaleidoscope of azure, white, crimson, magenta, turquoise female faces that salute the disheveled clouds of modernity and civilization, their hearts pulsating, their nimble fingers embracing one, two, three, four bit, byte, megabytes and infinity…

This story was written for World Pulse’s Women Weave the Web Digital Action Campaign. Learn more »

Downloads

Comments

Y's picture

Remarkable balance in the

Remarkable balance in the questions you pose, Sreesup, a wonderful basis for much rich debate and further study.

Y

Elizabeth Kipp-Giusti's picture

Thank you for sharing

As I read this article, I realized that there is a valuable conversation that has been left out of the digital campaign to help women. Your perspective, that the culturally-promoted desire for the possession of technology can be just as oppressive as the conditions of poverty, is germane. Consumerism is part of the picture, and it tempers the connectivity and power of technology. I applaud you for raising these questions. You've clearly done a lot of reading about the topic.

One thing I would recommend is to go back to your post and try to simplify the language. Some of your choices of words and phrasing made it very difficult to understand your point. As you read each line, as yourself "Do I need this to make my argument?" If you don't, take it out. I think you do your strong argument a disservice to have it be so difficult to understand.

A strong piece. Thanks for sharing!
-Elizabeth

missrok's picture

Important questions raised

Dear Sreesup,
I found your contribution very interesting and really appreciated how visual and rich is your writing. However, I have to admit that I got a little lost halfway into the text. I agree with you that what we like to perceive as digital revolution is not always as revolutionary as we would like it to be, it often perpetues existing divisions and inequalities. So far, so good.

But then you start writing about cyberfeminism (which I found very interesting by the way) and digital insurgency, while also mentioning prostitution and violence - could you please explain a bit more what are the points you would like to make here?

It would be also very interesting to hear more from you about possible solutions, is there something we can do to make digital revolution truly progressive and transformative?

Looking forward to read more of your thoughts, this was very inspiring!
Ania

milliej7's picture

passionate writing Sreetanwi

Thank you for sitting down and writing such a well-reserached and passionately-felt piece of writing Sreetanwi.
I like the fact that you look at some of the negative sides to the internet and technology. I appreciated the Indian context you gave your argument and the fact that you referred to a variety of Indian contexts, both urban and rural as well as giving personalised examples.

I do feel that the academic nature of your text makes it dense and not particularly reader-friendly. This text works well in certain contexts but perhaps won't reach as many people as it should because of its complexity. I agree with Elizabeth's advice, is there any way you could cut out any superfluous comment / language to simplify and strengthen your main arguments?

I would love to hear some of your suggestions of what is needed. What would help Indian woman in this complex, fragmented reality? Do you have a vision of what is needed?

Thanks again,
Jo

Ann Fishburn's picture

Thank you for your post!

Dear Sreetanwi Chakraborty,

Thank you for sharing your writing. I also agree with others here that the complex language of your writing makes the message difficult to find. Especially for online writing, language needs to be direct and simple as readers read quickly and need to see the most important messages in the first screen without scrolling. Simple more direct writing also help those who access the internet through a smartphone or other handheld device. Eliminate all words and phrases that do not aid understanding or convey meaning.

Your message is an important one and deserves to be understood! Thank you so much for your work and look forward to reading more from you in the future.

In hope and peace,
Ann Fishburn

Fiona J McKenzie's picture

A timely reminder

Dear Sreetani,

I found this an intriguing read and a well-balanced counterpoint to the view that the internet is a benign digital pathway to liberation for women. However, the medium isn't necessarily the message. The exploitation you point to, whether its excessive consumerism, negative body image, internet prostitution - all these have existed in different forms across the centuries. What has changed is the speed and reach of these 'messages'. But the net does also carry the potential for connecting women and making them aware of different ideas and different groups who can promote the validity of women's lives and their extraordinary potential.

I agree with the other reader's above - you have written a well-researched piece but the density makes it slightly difficult to follow. You make some very powerful points which would be even stronger if you pared away some of the phrases that you don't really need.

And it would be good to know what you think the answer is? Are you simply deeply negative about the internet and believe that change cannot be effected through digital means? It would be good to know.

Thank you for writing something that I found really interesting and I would love to debate this further with you if you want to get back in touch.

Best wishes,

Fiona

Fiona McKenzie

sallysmithr's picture

Great post!

I absolutely loved reading your post and you raised so many important questions. I think at first glance, as others have pointed out, technology means freedom and voice, and I love that you take a look from a different perspective and point out very valid points that were very interesting to read and contemplate. Your writing is very intriguing and I really enjoyed reading your thought on this.

Thanks again,

Sally

Leslie Stoupas's picture

Appreciated!

Sreetanwi,

I really appreciated your essay and the way that it showed the impact that the internet and other digital technologies can have on women. I wonder if this speaks to the need to educate internet and digital users differently? Surely there are socio-cultural problems that show up in the new mediums, but these mediums also change socio-cultural behaviors. You have really raised an intriguing point here, and I like that you support your argument with some of the academic research that has gone on around the use of digital media in general. I look forward to reading more of your work!

Leslie Stoupas

Jumi's picture

The other side of the debate, perhaps

Dear sreesup:

You raise some critical points and questions. Clearly you've invested time in reviewing some of the issues about digital divide, access and empowerment. I wonder how much of what you discuss here is obvious to the everyday woman who we could argue just needs to escape her everyday reality, not because she's vain but perhaps because that "escape" helps keep her sane. Or perhaps we need to wonder about those women who embraced technology not for narcissistic purposes, but because in order for them to appreciate the past, they need to live in the present and also prepare for the challenges of the future.

Karly N's picture

Thank you for this perspective!

Dear Streetanwi,

I would like to thank you for sharing this perspective with us at World Pulse, and for bringing up the incredibly important point of the vulnerability of women to media messages and how it can create false hope, and generate a desire to change one's own position to achieve higher status. Although we know that digital technology can be used for a wealth of positive connections and communications, I think it is important that you point out that technology can be used as a tactic of abuse and exploitation. I appreciate that you are not implicating women in this essay, but rather understanding that they are vulnerable and being taken advantage of. Thank you for helping to create awareness on this important topic!!

With gratitude,

Karly

JenMac's picture

Thank you for sharing!

Dear Streetanwi,

You are clearly a very gifted and articulate writer. What I took away from this article was a sense of you as a woman who is aware of the environment around her and the exploitation/oppression of women due to the digital consumerism within your own country and as a worldwide phenomenon/crises. That being said, in clearing stating that this problem exists and is unacceptable, what do you propose would be a way to address it? What would you like to see the final outcome being? Some ideas to think about for bringing this argument full circle.

Loved the language, loved the imagery, and enjoyed your references to books throughout!

In appreciation,
Jennie

Lylinaguas's picture

Thank you for sharing this.

Thank you for sharing this. You elaborately expressed your thoughts and experiences in this article. You raised issues and have certainly gone through a lot of effort to research and relate them to your own personal experiences. Digital consumerism has indeed influenced us in our preferences and priorities. But i believe more importantly, it has also opened an avenue for the opportunists who can take advantage and manipulate the less technologically equipped ones, exposing them to some degree of danger or vulnerability.

You are very articulate in your choice of vocabulary. From the perspective of a simple reader, however, I think the flow of the reader's interest would be heightened more if there were less adjectives and shorter and simpler descriptions to focus more on the subject being emphasized.

Best regards and good luck on all your endeavors.

Lylin

mimiryan's picture

Raising Important Questions

Dear Streetanwi,

You raise very valid points here and do so effectively. As I read this, I imagined you delivering it as powerful speech in which your audience would be left perplexed because you have raised so many complex issues surrounding cultural shifts due to technology. You are making us think and I appreciate your pointing out the other side of internet, which is plaguing our world and contributing to various human rights violations against women and children. What is happening to our values and is the internet doing more harm than good? Do you have ideas about viable solutions?

Thank you for articulating with such detail this side of the digital world that we must address and eradicate.

I hope that you use your spoken voice on this matter as you have done here. Such important work you are doing!

Mimi

Magazine »

Read global coverage through women's eyes

PHOTO ESSAY: The Dreams in Their Eyes

PHOTO ESSAY: The Dreams in Their Eyes

Community »

Connect with women on the ground worldwide

On Women's Agency in Southern Africa

On Women's Agency in Southern Africa

Campaigns »

Be heard at influential forums

WWW: Women Weave the Web

WWW: Women Weave the Web

Programs »

Help us train women citizen journalists

World Pulse Voices of Our Future

World Pulse Voices of Our Future

Blog »

Read the latest from World Pulse headquarters

Welcome, Women in the World!

Welcome, Women in the World!

Partners »

Join forces with our wide network of partners

Nobel Women's Initiative

Nobel Women's Initiative