Community Update

World Pulse Toolkits Available!

At World Pulse, we recognize the need for ongoing learning—for you and for your community! Our toolkits are all available here.

We are especially excited to share our signature Citizen Journalism and Digital Empowerment Curriculum. Start learning today!

People without a Nation

Stateless people in the state of limbo

Battle lines are being drawn at the Supreme Court. They are between the stateless and the state and they are about citizenship laws.

A draft court ruling grants citizenship to a child born from a Nepali mother and a Nepali father, a stark contrast from the Citizenship Act of 2006 and the 2011 Supreme Court directive that provides citizenship to a child born from a Nepali mother or a Nepali father. The debate between ‘and’ and ‘or’ has characterised the current discourse on citizenship with strong notions of gender bias and patriarchal hegemony. True enough, this has dislodged approximately 2.1 million persons, out of an estimated 30 million Nepali population, relegating them to ‘people without a nation’.

Nepal does not have any measures to safeguard against the possibility of statelessness for children born in Nepali territory, a violation of Article 7 of the Convention on the Rights of the Child. Though Nepal has been a party to this convention since 1990, it still does not state that it will facilitate the naturalisation of stateless children.

Based on international laws, there are different ways to get citizenship. One is through right to blood (jus sanguinis), the second through right of soil (jus soli), the third through a process of naturalisation, the fourth through choice and the fifth through acquisition of territory.

However, things take a different stride in Nepal. A foreign spouse is only eligible to take Nepali citizenship after 15 years of legal residence in Nepal, leaving their children in a state of limbo. Additionally, dual citizenship for Nepalis is strictly forbidden and the acquisition of a foreign nationality automatically renders a person’s existing Nepali citizenship invalid.

“The state is treating us like dirt and we are cowering like wimps,” says one such stateless person. “This country is annihilating us with impunity and we are not given any right to rage and rail over it,” says another. The citizenship law speaks of the selective perception of legal rights; it speaks of selective morality on who is a ‘native’ in one’s country. These ordinary people, who are not recognised in their own nation, are prevented from realising their rights and are clamoring for their national identity.

Nepal is at the crossroads of a fledgling democracy and is struggling to achieve common understanding on the process of nation building. It is said that there will never be democracy unless all aspects of human rights are covered. This is not as easy as it sounds. For one, stateless people are stripped of a citizenship certificate, the primary identity document used in Nepal that provides them access to services such as banking, obtaining a passport, medical treatment at hospitals, social security, government allowances and employment opportunities.

And this ordeal is far from over. For Nepali women, securing citizenship for their children who were not accepted or recognised by their husbands is almost impossible. How much worse is it for those who were raped, abused and impregnated? Just looking at the extent and depth of their emotional and physical ordeals, anyone would ask themselves why in god’s name should they have to pay for this?

Some Nepali politicians have defend the new citizenship rules, saying that Nepal needs to protect the interests of its people from the growing dominance of its neighbouring countries—India and China. In a report published in 2011, Pradeep Gyawali, a former parliamentarian and member of the panel that recommended the new citizenship rules, said, “We need to tighten the rules otherwise a small country like ours cannot take the pressure from big neighbours,” admitting that it was to discourage Indians and Chinese from seeking Nepali nationality.

However, bear in mind that stateless people are a threat to democratic ideals. You would imagine that this was happening in Syria or some war-torn part of the world. Ironically, the threat is not outside but is within. The Election Commission of Nepal indicates that a number of stateless people did not vote in 2008, and unless the restrictive provisions on citizenship are changed, this could lead to significant serious threats to internal peace, stability and security in the near future. If people are stateless on their own soil, they become a disenfranchised community with no political, social and moral allegiance to their own country.

Recent events have shown that Dzhokhar and Tamerlan’s inability to become fully integrated into American society appears to be their primary motive behind the Boston marathon bombings. A newspaper report stated that family, friends and social media sources painted a complex picture of the brothers’ religiosity, and especially how Tamerlan Tsarnaev’s struggle to fit into American culture was a seething rage that finally exploded.

The principle of attaining citizenship is closely tied with equality and the denial of citizenship has created problems for many. Stateless people can be arbitrary detained, exiled and confined with no rights to freedom. The denial of citizenship also restricts a person his basic rights to hold property in Nepal and gives a feeling of humiliation since one is treated like a foreigner.

As Nepal’s election draws close, the people who have remained stateless are looking to the new constitution for protection and relief. They expect greater protection of fundamental rights for minorities, women, the marginalised and vulnerable groups. These rights include women’s rights, rights for the stateless, LGBTs, ethnicity, religion tolerance, freedom of speech, children’s rights, indigenous rights and so on. However, the government has continuously sidelined the citizenship issue as less important than state restructuring and has shown an unwillingness to work together on statelessness.

While it is true that Nepal should guard itself against pre-conceived threats from neighbouring countries, the price of passing the wrong citizenship legislation for the right reasons is too high to pay. When things are not in their right perspective, the deprivation of human rights can cause conflict in the long run.

For years, Nepal campaigned to break away from traditional feudal structures. However, if constitutional and political reform is to be meaningful, this issue needs to be addressed to ensure that citizenship becomes a fundamental right available for all legitimate Nepali people. In the scheme of things, Nepal needs to understand that humanity begins at home.

Cabrido is an international news stringer assigned in Kathmandu
This story appeared in The Kathmandu Post on October 18, 2013.
See link (http://www.ekantipur.com/the-kathmandu-post/2013/10/17/oped/people-witho...)

Comments

JaniceW's picture

Insightful article

Chin, this is a wonderfully insightful article that provides solid background information on the complexity and consequences of statelessness.

While one would think the Nepali law straightforward, the fact that a child wishing to acquire his/her Nepali mother’s citizenship must have permanent residence in Nepal places a geographical restriction on the children of Nepalese women and foreign men who desire Nepalese citizenship. Since women are not allowed to pass on citizenship in the same way as men, it also raises issues of gender discrimination. As you say, securing legal proof of citizenship can be very difficult for women, especially when male family members refuse to assist them or are unavailable to do so. Denying women proof of citizenship then becomes an expedient way of ensuring that they cannot assert their rights to marital property, inheritance, or land.

Let's hope that Nepal's supreme court sees how narrow and conservative by international standards the proposals are and refuses to ratify them.

cscabrido's picture

Thanks Janice for sharing

Thanks Janice for sharing your insights here. Nepal is conducting its national elections this Nov 2013 and many stateless people will not be able to vote - a right that has stripped off from due due to statelessness issues. I do hope that the government makes this a priority issue so that the stateless people can have access to basic services such as education , banking and employment opportunities.

Wendyiscalm's picture

Thank you for your article.

Thank you for your article. You bring to attention what we need to learn. I personally do not know much about this but with your help we are all learning and that is the beginning of change. You make a difference. You matter.

Thank you again.

Ubuntu (I am who I am because of who we are together),

Wendy

Wendy Stebbins
Founder/CEO
I AM ONE IN A MILLION Non-Profit Organization focused on helping street orphans and vulnerable children in Livingstone, Zambia Africa.

cscabrido's picture

Dear Wendy, Thank you for

Dear Wendy,

Thank you for sharing your thoughts. And I am happy to know that these issues are being shared and exposed to other communities outside Nepal. The stateless people need help in letting their stories go out in a wider community.

Cheers,

Chin

Wendyiscalm's picture

Yes, you are right. And one

Yes, you are right. And one way to make sure that happens is by your articles making us responsible to do something to help so you provide a good service. Thank you. Don;t give up. Keep them coming.

Love and Ubuntu ( I am who I am because of who we are together),

Wendy

Wendy Stebbins
Founder/CEO
I AM ONE IN A MILLION Non-Profit Organization focused on helping street orphans and vulnerable children in Livingstone, Zambia Africa.

Magazine »

Read global coverage through women's eyes

Letters to a Better World

Letters to a Better World

Community »

Connect with women on the ground worldwide

VIRGIN ISLANDS: Queens Igniting Fire Ending Violence

VIRGIN ISLANDS: Queens Igniting Fire Ending Violence

Campaigns »

Be heard at influential forums

WWW: Women Weave the Web

WWW: Women Weave the Web

Programs »

Help us train women citizen journalists

World Pulse Voices of Our Future

World Pulse Voices of Our Future

Blog »

Read the latest from World Pulse headquarters

World Pulse Launches our Inaugural Community Advisory Board!

World Pulse Launches our Inaugural Community Advisory Board!

Partners »

Join forces with our wide network of partners

Nobel Women's Initiative

Nobel Women's Initiative