Community Update

World Pulse Toolkits Available!

At World Pulse, we recognize the need for ongoing learning—for you and for your community! Our toolkits are all available here.

We are especially excited to share our signature Citizen Journalism and Digital Empowerment Curriculum. Start learning today!

Murdering Merit!

say_no_to_reservation.jpg

Aliya Bashir

Huzaifa Khan, 22, had been waiting in the long queue at the University of Kashmir since the morning, excited to get her admission form. She was surprised to see girls making another line in the opposite direction, and boldly asked them, “Why are you making another line?” In unison, several answered, “We are Reserved Category.”
With a little annoyance, she couldn’t muster the courage to further carry on the conversation, so she kept silent. But she couldn’t stop the mad race of thoughts running through her head, and asked herself, “Would I be denied the basic rights, as I am not lucky enough like these girls, who don’t need to compete with me on the basis of merit, as they are reserved!”
Huzaifa belongs to the ‘open merit’ category, and cannot benefit from the reservation quota, neither in education nor in employment. She belongs to the ‘General Category’ who has to compete on the basis of high merit, without any concession.
Providing a reservation quota on the basis of caste and not on merit has deterred many educated and deserving students like Huzaifa, who say that there should be no exploitation of differences to take away the genuine rights of others.
“I am not against reservations, but I don’t think that the deserving persons actually avail the facilities of these quotas. We should strive for an equal share in socio-economic development and at other educational fronts. The weaker sections should be protected from social injustice,” Huzaifa says.
What is shocking to see is that instead of coming up with alternative innovative ideas to make sure that there is no discrimination on the basis of caste, creed and colour, the state government had recently declared 37 villages in the state as “Backward Areas.”Interestingly, over the past several years, there has been no elimination of any village from the Residents of Backwards Areas (RBA) list nor any measures taken by the government for the equal representation of people to make the caste system irrelevant.
But contrary to developmental trends, those profiting from the reservation system are increasingly people taking steps to get declared as “backwards,” which takes away benefits meant for the poor.
“The reality on the ground is that people from economically sound and educated backgrounds make the most use of the reserved seats, thus counteracting the spirit of reservations,” says Hamid Tantray, a government school teacher.
The majority of people in the valley who take the privilege of reservation quotas are already quite advanced in terms of educational and economic backgrounds. But because they still possess land in the so-called backwards areas, they are qualified for the reserved status.
On the basis of caste, area or profession, the Jammu and Kashmir government has categorised various reservations. The Schedule Tribe (ST) category has been also identified with their caste which includes Gujjars and Bakerwals, and the entire Schedule Cast (SC) population falls in the reserved category due to their poor economical conditions. Similarly, residents of backwards areas are assigned categories, owing to their geographical placement in various areas.
Overall, the state has 26 social castes, who each recieve 2% reservation under Other Backward Classes/Other Social Castes (OBC/OSC), which includes Haniji, Bhangi, Khakrob, Bhand, Barber (rural) Dambli /Faqir, Doom, Gada, Garati, Jheewar, Kulfiqar, Kumhar, Madari/Bazigar, Mirasi, Sansi, Shakhsaz, Shoe repairers, Shupri watal, Sikilighar, Teeli, Dhobi, Lohar and Tarkhan. These communities have been given reserved categories due to their professions and social castes.
The Jammu and Kashmir Reservation Act of 2004 provides reservation in appointment and admission in professional institutions for the members of Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and other socially and educationally “backward” groups. These groups receive 50% of the openings for education and employment opportunities, while the other 50% is left for open merit.
The Act clearly explains that the government may, on the recommendation of the State Backward Classes Commission, make inclusions in, and exclusions from the reserved categories. “Any person who obtains a certificate under the Act by misrepresentation, fraud or concealment of any material fact or impersonation shall, in addition to prosecution under the law for the time being in force, be liable to cancellation of the certificate and forfeiture of benefit, removal or dismissal from service; and fine of not less than ten thousand rupees”.
In 2009, a number of amendments were made to the Act, and a decision was made to not provide income to those who had completed their entire school education from an area identified as “backward” or within the Line of Control (the Line of Control (LOC) runs 742km (460 miles) dividing Indian- and Pakistan-controlled Kashmir, and acts as part of the de facto border between the two countries. The military frontline, which runs through inhospitable terrain, has separated hundreds of families and even divided villages and mountains. The LOC has been a flashpoint between the two nuclear-armed countries since its foundation. Their forces have exchanged gunfire across the line for years.). If schooling is not available in these areas, the person is required to move to the nearest adjoining area to pursue their education. This was a change from the previous ruling, which said that if the annual income of a person, from all sources, exceeded Rs 3 lacs (USD 6,030), they would be excluded from the category of socially and educationally “backward” classes.
In 1997, the state government passed the State Commission for Backward Classes Act, which is represented by a number of individuals from villages and social castes as listed in the commission under Section 8(2) of the Constitution. It has the same powers as that of a civil court and can call for evidence from any person to record and document evidence to grant reservation status, and consists of 53 indicators which are sent to the revenue authorities of the different districts of the state in order to receive the proper information, before granting the designation.
In order to recommend a village to be included in the category of “backward,” the Commission prepares a report from the relevant revenue authorities and determines their qualification. “The beneficiaries of the reservation are backed by revenue records which shows their properties and residential houses in the area which falls in the list of backward area. They belong to crème level who are mostly politicians, bureaucrats, police officers, businessmen and other high rank officers and are presently living in posh areas of the city,” says an officer at the State Commission for Backward Classes (SCBC). They then receive spots at schools and universities, as well as employment opportunities not based on their merits.
The officer also says that the unfortunate fact is that those people who benefit from the categorization flood the office with requests, and already have the necessary educational and financial conditions to succeed in life.
In addition, many of those who do benefit from the categorization, following completion of their education, move to cities, and thus leave behind those villages which gave them the status. They do not contribute back to the economic or social conditions of their communities. “The elite class whose ancestors basically are from villages mostly avail the category and their status never changes as the category status passes on and on to their future generations without any break. This exercise of reservation is totally futile and specifically oriented to trample over other’s genuine rights,” says Deeba Ashraf, a lecturer in a private college.
The government has put no barriers between the rich and poor of the same caste. While one enjoys the status due to their caste, the other suffers. There have been some instances where fraud has been identified and those found in violation have had degrees or jobs removed. However, there is no proper monitoring body to ensure that the system benefits only those who it should.
Due to this generalized discriminatory reservation system in the state, more and more people with lesser qualifications are preferred over those with merit. This process of nepotism paves the path to corruption and incompetently educated youth.
Many argue that instead of looking at reservations from a caste or backward point of view, it is better that to see it in the sense of helping those who are in need of actual help based on social and financial constraints. “We should not create barriers for the fundamental right of equality. Our efforts should be oriented to come out with resolutions and facts where we can have equal respect, status, opportunities and compete purely on the basis of our calibre and talent not to the section, community or class we belong to!” says Farmaan Javed, a practising doctor.
Apart from the discrimination that the people face both in terms of education and employability, there is an increasing rural and urban divide, where more and more youngsters feel that the urban populations unfairly enjoy the benefits of the reservations, while the rural people continue to feel looked down upon.
One solution lies in bridging the gap between these two groups – urban and rural - where both walk hand in hand not as enemies. Power cannot be concentrated in the hands of a few, but must be shared. This will only happen when the same kinds of facilities and opportunities are available in the rural areas, who can then compete more fairly.
Instead of encouraging more and more people to use these reservations, the government must work towards eliminating these reservation benefits provided to Schedule Castes, Schedule Tribes and Other Backwards Castes (SC/ST & OBCs). Educators and other experts view this system as an obstacle to positive development and growth, and say it leads to both discrimination as well as corruption.
While the path to abolishing this practice is still long, as caste systems are embedded in society and create many divides, in the meantime, the government must ensure that only those who legitimately qualify for and need this special assistance are those that receive it. This requires not only ending discrimination, but ensuring that the services that will allow all citizens of Kashmir to succeed on their own merits.
Huzaifa, after waiting for hours, collected the form without paying attention to the reserved category candidates, who were also waited patiently. “Merit needs to be the prime yardstick in any selection. A lack of sound economical background and other resources should not deter deserving persons from working their way up the ladder. For this, we need to discourage the caste system by becoming truly secular and abolishing all reservations in any form,” she said, before she left the campus.
Unfortunately, the caste-based reservations have taken such deep roots in the state that it would be political suicide for politicians to utter a word against it. After all, they also benefit from it. But if this issue is not dealt with now, then the policy of favouring a few on the basis of their birth will pave the way for a more biased state, which should be avoided under all circumstances. Already there is tension, and the possibility of conflict, due to anger and frustration on both sides.
People like Huzaifa, who have worked hard, must not be disadvantaged.
Reservations in any form need to be abolished in order for the state to truly prosper. Instead of encouraging more reservations, there is a need to devise a system where a bright, yet economically weak classes or individuals can compete fairly with others. Those that need extra assistance should be provided with educational opportunities – scholarships, books, even food – to give any students – not just those belonging to specific groups, with the opportunities they need to be able to compete with all.

This article is part of a writing assignment for Voices of Our Future a program of World Pulse that provides rigorous new media and citizen journalism training for grassroots women leaders. World Pulse lifts and unites the voices of women from some of the most unheard regions of the world.

Downloads

Comments

Stella Paul's picture

Yes its frustrating

Dear Aliya

I have seen it all over India. Till this day I remember a girl who made it to a medical college with marks far below 60%. She was empowered with a SC certificate. Today she is a doctor somewhere, treating patients who put their lives in her hand. How good is she? How many surgeries she is performing and botching up? And how many deserving candidates she beat with that caste certificate?

Its a two edged sword - without the quota, oppression continues. With the quota, deprivation. Thanks for this article!

Stella Paul
Twitter: @stellasglobe

Aliya Bashir's picture

Stella I agree

Dear Stella,
Thanx for exemplifying and sharing this story. You know what the story is almost same everywhere, where more and more deserving people are pushed to the wall and where from begins more horrible stories of discrimination, corruption, misusing power and mediocrity and what not. I pity those who enjoy the rights which they were never part of but to the illegal practices they literally snatched the genuine rights of the under privileged. What a shame for them!

AB

Pushpa Achanta's picture

Pertient comments

Dear Stella,

Thanks for your very apt words "Without the quota,.."

I think marks in the Indian education system (which we're familiar with and have emerged from) needn't reflect a student's knowledge, skills, etc. Are u certain that the girl that you're referring isn't a capable, empathetic doctor somewhere?

Love,
Pushpa

usha kc's picture

Aliya and Stella, I am with

Aliya and Stella, I am with you dearies as we are in Nepal also going through the same pain.

In Nepal, after democracy concept of inclusion developed and reservation in the name of caste,ethnicity is increased. I donot mean they should not get reservation but the frustration starts when a poor so called upper caste who holds good results can not get scholarship and a rich student whose family owns many building, vehicle gets the scholarship just due to being other than high caste. Is that justice????

thank you for choosing such an essential topic.

Aliya Bashir's picture

We share your pain

Priyea, deary Usha,
The injustice is same everywhere as this brutality will increase with more and materialism and power hungry people who want to build their own houses with the sweat and blood of poor. Lets be hopeful for a change and we have initiated that already with our discussions. Cheers to that :)

AB

amiesissoho's picture

Politicians never engage in

Politicians never engage in virgin areas to shake up the dominant practices & perceptions. It is individuals who realize that they have rights and have to fight for them as equal citizens. This shocks society for the first time the taboo is broken, then the dust settles down and they start reasoning. They start coming up with alternatives to stir debates while the politicians watch and listen until they eventually get involved. Keep fighting for what is yours.

Thanks Aliya.

Amie

Aliya Bashir's picture

Great Thought

Dear Amie you have put it so right, yet so simple that 'Keep fighting for what is yours', i ma touched. Hugs Amie. I think politicians cannot be singly hold responsible for this mess. Afterall, they are also among us. It is all about one's consciousness that how far one can go to snatch the rights of others and enjoy the pleasure that were never meant for him/her. If we will get self-realization, then i am sure all the evils will vanish without blame-game. It is high time that we all do our part in small doings, rather than expecting of something big without actually striving for that.

AB

Pushpa Achanta's picture

Intriguing perspective

Dear Aliya,

Thanks for this candid piece on an issue that's vital to South Asian society. I agree with many of your views but believe that reservation or affirmative action is necessary to benefit excluded groups. Like most policies and legislations, the challenges with this one are its implementation and political interference.

Btw, I believe that merit and grades are subjective and don't necessarily measure or define a person's ability.

Regards,
Pushpa

Aliya Bashir's picture

I am not Against Reservations!

My dear Pushpa,
Thank you for the encouragement. I totally agree with you that merit doesn't necessarily measure one's ability but what my trying to say is that the non-deserving blue-eyed people should not mar those who burn their midnight oil to get that selective admission or job, for which they had prepared for. It doesn't mean I am saying merit are best and those who get reservations are not.
I am also not against those who get reservation, but the reality is the deserving don't get their due share in actuality, which maligns this overall system which was meant for something else.
My views are based on my experiences and after talking with cross section of people, but that doesn't mean i am generalizing the whole thing nor are there any pre-assumptions.
Stay in touch dear.

AB

One of Many's picture

I am very impressed

Nice work, Aliya:

You do such an excellent job explaining this complex, deeply embedded system that I imagine has gotten more complex and interwoven over centuries. Probably the goals and needs of different groups and places and allegiances add to that complexity and make it all supremely frustrating. On the other hand it can seem simple: someone has a reservation, they get the place with hardly an effort, whereas others who work so hard do not.

Weaving the story of Huzaifa in with the explanation of the system of reservations was very helpful, and I appreciate hearing her words and emphasis. You did a good job making her come alive to us, and you made me want to stand right up there with you for her!

It is so frustrating that a change like this would take such a complex shift in the government, allegiances, social beliefs, and more. So many different perspectives, each with a different stake in it.

You handled this difficult topic very, very well, Aliya. Way to go!

Anna

Speaking my Peace

Aliya Bashir's picture

Loads of Thanx From Kashmir

Dear Anna,
Thanx you so much for such a boost and encouragement. I t really matters to us a lot. The complexity of the topic was very frustrating as you rightly pointed out, but thankfully with the greatness of Allah and sisters like you, I tried out my best to bring in some life so that people can relate to this injustice through systemic way to carpet the blue-eyed people and other undeserving lot. Although the idea was not bad to implement but as they say that we cannot always blame the system, cos its we who run, make and mar that. And if people are taking credit, why to blame system and not the individuals. As a stakeholder, we have a responsibility to say things, have our own stand and change the negative perspectives for a brighter future Inshallah.
Stay in touch and stay safe.

AB

MaDube's picture

Hmm

This is a very sensitive topic and I applaud you for your candid approach. Indeed, the question of quotas is always a sensitive question especially when it now appears as if those who used to be underprivileged have surpassed the supposedly privileged in being privileged. The question of merit always comes up whether it is a quota given to girls to access tertiary education as much as boys, or women accessing decision making positions as much as their male counterparts, and in your case marginalised classes in society accessing education as much as those that are historically privileged. I do agree with Pushpa and Stella that the quota is a necessary tool to redress past imbalances and without it, the beneficiaries would continue to be excluded to such an extent that is far more devastating than the situation where they do get privileged access though they may not be as deserving as other students. My experience living in a country where the quota system applied to access to tertiary education has proved that even though the girls needed lesser entry points than boys into university and college programmes, their performance was a s good and even more outstanding than the boys'.The question is about gaining access to the system-once they gain access I am sure they are not passed exams with lower scores than the rest of the students in medical school because then you begin to compromise a whole system and jeopardise the professions into which these people will be deployed.

Just my two cents..

MaDube

Aliya Bashir's picture

True Dear

The scenario varies, so it is quite difficult to generalise the things. It is a great experience to see my sisters from all over the globe relating themselves to my topic. It is a priveldge. With such activities, I thing my job fempwering is half done. Thanx to all you beautiful ladies out there.

AB

mrbeckbeck's picture

Interesting topic

Aliya, great work here on presenting a complex system. It's not as easy as saying "good" or "bad". You've managed to tease out some of the challenges within the quota practice, with great clarity. What an interesting debate you've started... I can see the need for the quota, but also see the need to enforce some limits on people who abuse it.

Very thought-provoking! Three cheers to you on this, and all of the previous assignments!
Best,
Scott

Scott Beck
World Pulse Online Community Manager

Aliya Bashir's picture

Thanx Scott

Ya, you pointed out rightly, that just saying good or bad is not enough, we have to see the pros and cons before actually jumping to conclusions. And, du to some vested intrests , we cannot totally ignore the other side of the coin, where reservation is much needed.
Great Boost Scott.

AB

Karoline's picture

Great article!

What a great article you've submitted - and a great debate as well! It's only when people start talking about these things that change can happen, and it looks like change is happening - starting right here!

Aliya Bashir's picture

Oh Yes! Change is here only

Mam it would have been never possible withour your support and love. Thanx a ton. We should do our partwithout waiting for others to start. We can't wat for some magical wand to brush off all our problems, we have to stand up and bring that change for a sustainable development ad peace.
Cheers

AB

Corine Milano's picture

Aliya, thanks for this

Aliya, thanks for this article. The other commenters are right—it's a complex and intricate topic that deserves deeper exploration. And you've done that! I'm impressed with your ability to succinctly explain the situation many face, while delving into the complexities that make this a hard-to-talk-about topic. I especially liked your use of a personal narrative to serve as an intro and outro for your story. It was a wonderful and compelling way to lead the reader through your piece. Great job!

Aliya Bashir's picture

Thanx for the encouragement

Dear Corine,
It so nice when people appreciate and more importantly, it helps us to do better so as to come up to the expectations. I am so glad to see when people from all parts of the globe express their important and much-needed views with Kashmir. Greetings from community. It really means so much for us.
My Dear friend Stella rightly says, "Words heal."

AB

Magazine »

Read global coverage through women's eyes

Letters to a Better World

Letters to a Better World

Campaigns »

Be heard at influential forums

WWW: Women Weave the Web

WWW: Women Weave the Web

Programs »

Help us train women citizen journalists

World Pulse Voices of Our Future

World Pulse Voices of Our Future

Blog »

Read the latest from World Pulse headquarters

World Pulse Launches our Inaugural Community Advisory Board!

World Pulse Launches our Inaugural Community Advisory Board!

Partners »

Join forces with our wide network of partners

Nobel Women's Initiative

Nobel Women's Initiative