Community Update

World Pulse Toolkits Available!

At World Pulse, we recognize the need for ongoing learning—for you and for your community! Our toolkits are all available here.

We are especially excited to share our signature Citizen Journalism and Digital Empowerment Curriculum. Start learning today!

Women next in the line of exploitation...

Zimbabwe's tobacco industry has been dogged by a myriad of challenges forcing otherwise honest individuals to turn to unscrupulous ways of making money. Having recently visited the tobacco auction floors, I noted some worrying trends and have a hunch that women are next in line for exploitation.

Due to the early start of the tobacco selling season in Zimbabwe this year, there is a shortage of packaging materials for wrapping the product. The packaging, commonly known by the manufacturer’s name as propaks, consists of khaki paper and sacks. Ordinarily, a roll of khaki paper should cover 60 bails while one huge sack will cover a bail of tobacco. The season normally starts in May but this year, Government made a decision to start in February. I won’t go into what we have been told are the pros and cons of the early start. However, one thing is for sure, farmers were ill-prepared for the early start to the season and so were other service providers, as evidenced by the shortage of propaks and the chaos that ensued, including snaking queues just to off-load the leaf at the auction floors earlier on in the season.

The pressure for the propaks, which are produced by one company, was quite serious and the monopoly had to enlist the support of the riot police first and later the ordinary police to maintain order as people jostled and almost turned riotous while trying to get the precious material. Without the packaging, farmers cannot transport their produce to the auction floors, which means they can not sell so their livelihood is affected and the business grinds to a halt.

As a result of the short supply of the propaks, people have to queue for hours on end for one roll of khaki paper and a maximum of 20 used sacks.

Naturally, where there is inefficiency, some individuals will look for ingenious ways to beat the system. In an effort to beat the system and having grown tired of queuing daily for more than four hours to buy the propaks, some merchant decided to use their ingenuity. They figured that since people with disabilities are sometimes exempted from queuing, perhaops it would make sense to hire blind “farmers,” whom they would accompany as “visual aids” and buy the packaging materials without hassles.

The “visual aid,” trick, however, did not work. Some like-minded people also who figured that since people over the age of 65 don’t usually queue, they might as well hire someone elderly whom they could claim was their frail grandfather and use him to jump the line.

However, what seemed like a good plan almost caused a riot and the tricksters, both visual aids and grandsons, were sent scampering to the back of the queue. Sadly, none of the tricksters were farmers. They were traders who capitalize on shortages and create a parallel market where they resell scarce products at inflated prices. Given the prevailing situation with the propaks, it is not surprising that a parallel market has sprouted. While on the formal market a roll of khaki paper costs US$135, a brand new sack costs $3.50 and a used one costs $2.40, on the parallel market the khaki paper costs $130 but will cover less than 60 bails and a sack costs $8.

I wonder though, if the dear souls who were willing to rent out their disability and age were paid the full sum, seeing as their services were not fully utilized.

This points to a worrying possibility as I noticed that there is a separate queue for women, which is more orderly and moves faster hence all women managed to buy their propaks without difficulty. I suspect a lot of male traders will invest in recruiting women “farmers” to buy propaks on their behalf. I imagine the line of “women farmers” quiuing to buy propaks will soon be longer than that of the “male farmers.”

Given the economic challenges that many women face as a result of the use of multiple foreign currencies in Zimbabwe, the few dollars that these merchants may offer women could go a long way in providing much-needed income. My only advice is that the women who agree to be exploited should ensure they get paid in full.

Mmmm, isn’t it amazing though, what people will do for the love of money?

By Matilda Moyo
4 June 2010

Comments

jluoh's picture

The imperfection of money

Matilda,

Thanks for the great insight into the lives of Zimbabwe Tobacco farmers. Money itself is not evil, but the desire for money could get out of hands. Having lived in China where the influx of foreign investments since the late 1970s have literally changed people's lives from communistic sharers to money-grabbers acting in self-interest for profit. (Hence the situations with the baby formula, toy poisonings, etc.) We, the Chinese call that, "eyes red for money." I am not promoting communism, but capitalism isn't without its faults.

Thinking about it, society sometimes drives these old men, blind people, and women to become the vulnerable victims of an imperfect and corrupted system. Even though they voluntarily took the position, but as the season changes, or a new law is put in, they will all be out of a job. Interesting, because these are the people who have the most problem finding a proper, stable, and legal income source anywhere in the world.

Just my two cents.
Thank you!!
Jen

dr edonna's picture

Agreeing with Jen

Yes, I have to agree with Jen, because the world is not created equal when it comes to money. Some countries had an early jump on exploiting others through enslavement and colonialism, and let us not forget, this was the basis of capitalism, the exploitation of people and the exportation of people utilizing them as free labor. So, now, don't go blaming the victims, those who now have a short stick to fish with because they did not begin exploiting people so early in the game to become the riches and most powerful money launders in the world!! We must always keep the current trends that are a response to ancient historical events that now affect the way economies run.

Yes, there are a lot of desperate people in Africa, because there is no welfare, system or much government support, hence people have to fend for themselves by working for themselves, and that pushes the competition between people to the ultimate limit that looks like a love for money when in fact it is the need to survive above all else they are fighting for. Africa is no worse in corruption than other countries in the world, but it is seeking to compete with countries who had a jump on great economies at the expense of Africans. Remember the past lest we forget how we ended up at the bottom of the economic game.

CArolyn Brown's picture

To Any Body

Thank you Matilda.

I'm Sorry if the Situation Gets Worse.

NEw to Pulse World

P.S. It took alot of emtion to get that out. How could this change if not redirected to resourceful means?

Magazine »

Read global coverage through women's eyes

PHOTO ESSAY: The Dreams in Their Eyes

PHOTO ESSAY: The Dreams in Their Eyes

Community »

Connect with women on the ground worldwide

On Women's Agency in Southern Africa

On Women's Agency in Southern Africa

Campaigns »

Be heard at influential forums

WWW: Women Weave the Web

WWW: Women Weave the Web

Programs »

Help us train women citizen journalists

World Pulse Voices of Our Future

World Pulse Voices of Our Future

Blog »

Read the latest from World Pulse headquarters

Welcome, Women in the World!

Welcome, Women in the World!

Partners »

Join forces with our wide network of partners

Nobel Women's Initiative

Nobel Women's Initiative